How to solve an ODE with 2 initial conditions and 2 unknown parameters and 3 boundary conditions (overdetermined?)

30 views (last 30 days)
I have an ODE of the form
where a and b are unknown parameters, and F(t) is a fractional function: e.g.
The initial conditions are
Because a and b are unknown, the soultion of the ODE is depeding on a and b.
The solution x has to fulfill these boundary conditions in the time interval :
(where K is a known constant, e.g. )
(where )
( the maximum of the derivative of the solution is v, where v is a known velocity, e.g. )
The first problem is, that the linear system of equations to solve for a and b is overdetermined, because there are 3 eqantions for 2 unknowns. The second problem is, that i cant use the symbolic toolbox to compute the solution of the ODE, because of the broken rational function F(t) (it takes far too long, approx. more than 10 hours).
Would bvp4c or bvp5c be suitable for my problem? If so, then how to use them. And if not, is there anything else i could try?
Alan Stevens
Alan Stevens on 29 Oct 2020
@Walter: My values for a and b are quite possibly wrong - they only get the maximum xdot reasonably (Looks like I was trying for xf = 0.5 instead of 5. Hmm, I can't even see where the value of 0.5 was specified now!). As you say, the spec changed a few times. No matter what initial guesses I made for a and b, fminsearch always returned positive a and negative b, even if my initial guesses were both positive.

Sign in to comment.

Accepted Answer

Alan Stevens
Alan Stevens on 28 Oct 2020
The following is as close as I can get. You might be able to do better by altering tolerances using setoptions, but I'll leave that to you:
tspan = [0 0.25];
a = 1.5*10^5; b = -5*10^6;
AB0 = [a; b];
AB = fminsearch(@search,AB0,[],tspan);
a = AB(1); b = AB(2);
disp(' a b')
disp([a, b])
IC = [0 0];
[t, X] = ode45(@(t,x) fn(t,x,AB),tspan,IC);
x = X(:,1);
v = X(:,2);
function FF = search(AB,tspan)
K = 0.5;
vmax = 3.6;
[~,X] = odesol(AB,tspan);
xf = X(end,1);
vm = max(X(:,2));
vf = X(end,2);
FF = (K-xf)^2 + (vmax - vm)^2 + vf^2;
function [t,X] = odesol(AB,tspan)
IC = [0 0];
[t, X] = ode45(@(t,x) fn(t,x,AB),tspan,IC);
function dXdt = fn(t,X,AB)
m = 30000;
a = AB(1);
b = AB(2);
x = X(1);
v = X(2);
dXdt = [v;
(a*v + b*x + 1110000*(t-0.0331)^2/(t+0.0371)^2 + 882900)/m];
This produces
e_frog on 29 Oct 2020
I made both the version with 1 ODE and 2 ODEs work for me. But the downside is, that the solutions never match the boundary conditions exactly.
For example: for 1 ODE the boundary condition is not met, the resut for that is always how do I adjust the tolerances so that the conditions are met better (or maybe met exactly)? For the system with 2 ODEs the conditions are way off.
E.g.: Goal: , but actual result:

Sign in to comment.

More Answers (0)

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!