How to solve 'Error using symengine. Invalid input. 'expression' is expected.'?

16 views (last 30 days)
Variables that have been defined: Ta(array),Tc(array), alpha(number), gammar(array). Undefined variables: Tz(sym). I wanna solve for Tz
syms Tz mcphayphayvz
mcv=19.806+(0.00419/2).*Ta
mcphayphayvz=19.806+(0.00419/2).*Tz+0.5.*Tz.*((360.34+252.4*alpha)^(10^-5))
mcphayvc=(mcv+gammar.*mcphayphayvz)./(1+gammar)
Tz=solve('Tz=(((xiz*(QH-deltaQH))./(M1.*(1+gammar)))+mcphayvc.*Tc)./(betaz.*mcphayphayvz)',Tz)

Accepted Answer

Star Strider
Star Strider on 20 Apr 2018

Delete the single quotes, and add a ‘double equal’:

Tz=solve(Tz == (((xiz*(QH-deltaQH))./(M1.*(1+gammar)))+mcphayvc.*Tc)./(betaz.*mcphayphayvz), Tz)

That will at least not throw the same error.

More Answers (1)

Walter Roberson
Walter Roberson on 20 Apr 2018
syms Ta Tc alpha gammar Tz xiz QH deltaQH M1 betaz
mcv=19.806+(0.00419/2).*Ta 
mcphayphayvz=19.806+(0.00419/2).*Tz+0.5.*Tz.*((360.34+252.4*alpha)^(10^-5))
mcphayvc=(mcv+gammar.*mcphayphayvz)./(1+gammar) 
eqn = Tz==(((xiz*(QH-deltaQH))./(M1.*(1+gammar)))+mcphayvc.*Tc)./(betaz.*mcphayphayvz);
Tzsol = solve(eqn, Tz)

Note that Ta Tc gammar must be scalar values for this purpose. If they were arrays then the solve() would be trying to find one single Tz that solved all of the values simultaneously.

If you are trying to get a solution for each corresponding Ta, Tc, gammar, then you can

subs(Tzsol, {Ta, Tc, gammar}, {Ta_array, Tc_array, gammar_array})

Also note that a pair of solutions are found. It looks like it might be two solutions for a quadratic.

  4 Comments
Vuong Hoang
Vuong Hoang on 21 Apr 2018
Edited: Vuong Hoang on 21 Apr 2018

Thx for advices. I tried specific value (row 1,column 5401) in Ta,Tc,gammar,betaz(also an array) and get 'sub2ind -> out of range subscript error'. I doubt my equation is never satisfied.

 %code: 
syms Tz
mcv=19.806+(0.00419/2).*Ta(1,5401)
mcphayphayvz=19.806+(0.00419/2).*Tz+0.5.*Tz.*((360.34+252.4*alpha)^(10^-5))
mcphayvc=(mcv+gammar(1,5401).*mcphayphayvz)./(1+gammar(1,5401)) 
eqn = Tz==(((xiz*(QH-deltaQH))/(M1*(1+gammar(1,5401))))+mcphayvc*Tc(1,5401))/(betaz(1,5401).*mcphayphayvz);
Tzsol = solve(eqn, Tz)
Tz = double(Tzsol);
Walter Roberson
Walter Roberson on 21 Apr 2018

If betaz is an array then you need to

syms Ta_s Tc_s alpha gammar_s Tz xiz QH deltaQH M1 betaz_s
mcv=19.806+(0.00419/2).*Ta_s 
mcphayphayvz=19.806+(0.00419/2).*Tz+0.5.*Tz.*((360.34+252.4*alpha)^(10^-5))
mcphayvc=(mcv+gammar_s.*mcphayphayvz)./(1+gammar_s) 
eqn = Tz==(((xiz*(QH-deltaQH))./(M1.*(1+gammar_s)))+mcphayvc.*Tc_s)./(betaz_s.*mcphayphayvz);
Tzsol = solve(eqn, Tz)
Tz = double( subs(Tzsol, {Ta_s, Tc_s, gammar_s, betaz_s}, {Ta, Tc, gammar, betaz}) );

If you only want one particular location you could

Tz5401 = double( subs(Tzsol, {Ta_s, Tc_s, gammar_s, betaz_s}, {Ta(5401), Tc(5401), gammar(5401), betaz(5401)}) );

Sign in to comment.

Products

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!