Triangulate a non-convex point set
Show older comments
I have a set of points in 3D that define the surface of a non-convex object, I would like to generate some kind of triangulation of these points so as to plot this surface. Any ideas how I might do this?
The convex hull won't work, because my points are on the surface of a non-convex body. I'm aware that the problem of defining a non-convex hull is ill-posed and has no unique solution. One way to go is the alpha-shape, and there is a file on the FEX that does this, but I was wondering if there is another (better) way?
9 Comments
Sean de Wolski
on 21 Nov 2013
Do you know which vertices are connected to each other on the surface.?
Oliver
on 21 Nov 2013
Sean de Wolski
on 21 Nov 2013
alpha shapes...
Houssem
on 17 Feb 2014
Hi,
In my work, i need to get a mesh surface of non-convex 3D object it must verifies the spherical topology (satisfies Euler theorem : V-E+F=2). I have a 3D position of vertices [X Y Z] and faces of a non-convex 3D object.
I used under matlab the function "convhulln" to get spherical topology mesh surface. The obtained mesh surface is satisfied Euler theorem but the object is deformed.
How i can generate a spherical topology mesh surface of non-convex object
Thank you again
John D'Errico
on 17 Feb 2014
Edited: John D'Errico
on 17 Feb 2014
I concur with Sean. Alpha shapes are a good solution. CRUST is another, but I don't know if there is a code on the FEX for that. I'm not sure why Oliver resists the idea of alpha shapes. Perhaps he can say why, and we might be able to show him why he is wrong.
If the issue is simply that an alpha shape generates an entire triangulation, and not just the hull, it is trivial to compute that boundary surface for an alpha shape.
Houssem
on 17 Feb 2014
Thank you for your reply,
Alpha shapes has a spherical topology? (satisfies Euler theorem)
Best
I have the same problem that Oliver has. In my case, alpha-shapes doesn't work. I suppose you are using this file http://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/fileexchange/28851-alpha-shapes. Could you help me? I attach the set of points.
Antonio
on 3 Mar 2014
Sorry, you're right, it works. But it's not perfect.
In my case, if I set a low radius, some areas are not shown in the triangulation. But if I set a higher radius, the non-convex edge is distorted.
You can check this problem using my previous attachment.
I hope you could help me a bit...
Sean de Wolski
on 15 Oct 2014
Antonio, the R2014b alpha shape provides the alpha spectrum so you can see all radii that affect the hull.
Answers (1)
Sean de Wolski
on 15 Oct 2014
Edited: Sean de Wolski
on 15 Oct 2014
0 votes
As of MATLAB R2014b, there is now a 2d and 3d alphaShape tool built into MATLAB.
Categories
Find more on Delaunay Triangulation in Help Center and File Exchange
Products
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!