How to use MESHGRID or NDGRID instead of multiple FOR-Loop?

6 views (last 30 days)
Dear coder, Briefly, the program objective was to evaluate all possible constant pairs for a different set of condition. Since there are SIX constant, the current implementation required SIX nested FOR-loop. However, the code looks so messy.
for f_p_kdeA=s.p_kdeA
for f_p_kdeF=s.p_kdeF
for f_p_PrmSq00=s.p_PrmSq00
for f_p_PrmSq01=s.p_PrmSq01
for f_p_PrmSq10=s.p_PrmSq10
for f_p_PrmSq11=s.p_PrmSq11
s=eval_s(s);
end
end
end
end
end
end
Thus, I wonder how to make the following code to be more efficient by eliminating the FOR-loops. Thru some reading, using the NDGRID is a possible ways to make the code more efficient. However, I have limited knowledge on how to implement it. I really appreciate if someone can point out on how to do it.
The complete code is a below
[comb,s]=ini();
comb= eval_forLoop(comb,s);
result=array2table(comb);
result.Properties.VariableNames=s.HeaderName;
function [comb,s]=ini()
load('stt_table.mat')
data=table2array(stt_table);
[s.state.kde,s.state.prm,s.state.sq]=deal(data(:,1),data(:,2),data(:,3));
s.p_kdeA=0:0.5:1;
s.p_kdeF=0:0.5:1;
s.p_PrmSq00=0:0.5:1;
s.p_PrmSq01=0:0.5:1;
s.p_PrmSq10=0:0.5:1;
s.p_PrmSq11=0:0.5:1;
nRow=(numel(s.p_kdeA))*(numel(s.p_kdeF))*(numel(s.p_PrmSq00))*...
(numel(s.p_PrmSq01))*(numel(s.p_PrmSq10))*(numel(s.p_PrmSq11));
comb=nan(nRow,7);
end
function comb= eval_forLoop(comb,s)
c_d=1;
for f_p_kdeA=s.p_kdeA
for f_p_kdeF=s.p_kdeF
for f_p_PrmSq00=s.p_PrmSq00
for f_p_PrmSq01=s.p_PrmSq01
for f_p_PrmSq10=s.p_PrmSq10
for f_p_PrmSq11=s.p_PrmSq11
s.table1=[f_p_kdeA;f_p_kdeF];
s.table2=[f_p_PrmSq00;f_p_PrmSq01;f_p_PrmSq10;f_p_PrmSq11];
s=eval_s(s);
comb(c_d,:)= [s.avrge_aa;f_p_kdeA;f_p_kdeF;f_p_PrmSq00;...
f_p_PrmSq01; f_p_PrmSq10;f_p_PrmSq11];
c_d=c_d+1;
end
end
end
end
end
end
end
%

Accepted Answer

balandong
balandong on 16 Nov 2017
Credit to KSSV & Andrei Bobrov, their proposed idea lead to the solution below.
KSSV: His idea allow more flexibility for the spacing interval.
Andrei Bobrov: The end result of the a = [a{:}]; is what desired.
Proposed solution
s.p_kdeA=0:0.2:1;
s.p_kdeF=0:0.5:1;
s.p_PrmSq00=0:0.5:1;
s.p_PrmSq01=0:0.5:1;
s.p_PrmSq10=0:0.02:1;
s.p_PrmSq11=0:0.5:1;
S = struct2cell(s) ;
CpTable = cell(6,1);
[CpTable{end:-1:1}] = ndgrid(S{:}) ;
CpTable = cellfun(@(x)x(:),CpTable,'un',0);
CpTable = [CpTable{:}];

More Answers (2)

KSSV
KSSV on 15 Nov 2017
s.p_kdeA=0:0.5:1;
s.p_kdeF=0:0.5:1;
s.p_PrmSq00=0:0.5:1;
s.p_PrmSq01=0:0.5:1;
s.p_PrmSq10=0:0.5:1;
s.p_PrmSq11=0:0.5:1;
S = struct2cell(s) ;
[I{1:numel(S)}] = ndgrid(S{:}) ;
I
  1 Comment
balandong
balandong on 16 Nov 2017
Edited: balandong on 16 Nov 2017
Thanks for your answer, it really compact, really appreciate it.

Sign in to comment.


Andrei Bobrov
Andrei Bobrov on 15 Nov 2017
a = cell(6,1);
[a{end:-1:1}] = ndgrid(0:.5:1);
a = cellfun(@(x)x(:),a,'un',0);
a = [a{:}];
And rewrite your functions eval_s and etc for new variable a!
  1 Comment
balandong
balandong on 16 Nov 2017
Thanks for the fast response. Your solution work like a charm, really appreciate it.

Sign in to comment.

Categories

Find more on Resizing and Reshaping Matrices in Help Center and File Exchange

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!