Different answers for the result of integration and summation

1 view (last 30 days)
Hello. I'd like to get the result of this expression for k=1 and m=1
I prepared the simple code
function z=self_energy1
t=-0.000689609;
T_c=0.242731;
mu=0.365908;
k=1;
N=-1000:1000;
nn=10^4;
fun1=@(a,q) a.*tanh((a.^2-mu)/(2*T_c)).*log((2*a.^2+2*a*q+q^2-2*mu-1i*2*pi*N*T_c)./(2*a.^2-2*a*q+q^2-2*mu-1i*2*pi*N*T_c))/q-2;
fun2=@(q) t+integral(@(a)fun1(a,q),0,nn,'AbsTol',1e-6,'RelTol',1e-3,'ArrayValued',true);
fun3=@(q,m) T_c*q/k*log((-k^2+2*k*q-q^2+mu+1i*2*pi*N*T_c-1i*(2*m+1)*pi*T_c)./(-k^2-2*k*q-q^2+mu+1i*2*pi*N*T_c-1i*(2*m+1)*pi*T_c));
fun4=@(q,m) fun3(q,m)/fun2(q);
S=@(q,m) sum(fun4(q,m));
y1=integral(@(q)S(q,1),0.0001,nn,'AbsTol',1e-6,'RelTol',1e-3,'ArrayValued',true)
end
but the final result depends the point in the function4, i.e. if I set point fun4=@(q,m) fun3(q,m)./fun2(q) then I have one result and if no point there fun4=@(q,m) fun3(q,m)/fun2(q) I get another answer.
Could you tell me what is the correct syntax for the evaluating this expression? Thank you in a advance for your help.
  2 Comments
Aquatris
Aquatris on 6 Jul 2018
The dot division is element-wise division, meaning i th element of the first matrix is divided by i th element of the second matrix. If there is no dot, it is a matrix division. In your case, I think you need the dot division since you need to evaluate the expression seperatly for each q and N values.
Yuriy Yerin
Yuriy Yerin on 7 Jul 2018
Thank you for you response. I know about the meaning of the dot division but I was confused that I got wrong result of this expression obtained earlier by another approach (Fortran). So that's why I decided to ask community in hope that somebody pays attention on my possible mistake. Anyway thanks again.

Sign in to comment.

Answers (0)

Categories

Find more on Mathematics in Help Center and File Exchange

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!