Reduction variables on the GPU II and arrayfun: cannot assign to parent function variable?
5 views (last 30 days)
Show older comments
Hello,
This is (hopefully) a simple reduction variable question for performing parallel GPU operations onto a single value. I have read the tutorial on stencil processing and frankly do not understand why this does not work.
A simple example is below (not intended to be actually used, stand in for more complicated operations). Here, I am taking some vector array, using a gpu arrayfun to get the difference between neighbors, and then trying to sum those differences to a single variable. Since the difference operation is order independent, and the result is summed onto a single variable, I figured a comination of arrayfun + a reduction variable using nested functions would be the best way to start.
function v = reductionVariableLoopTest()
x = gpuArray.rand(100,1);
v = gpuArray.zeros(1);
function d = difFun(ind)
d = x(ind+1) - x(ind);
end
function sumFun(ind)
v = v + difFun(ind);
end
vect = gpuArray.colon(1,length(x)-1);
arrayfun(@sumFun,vect);
end
However, this gives the error: Assignment of parent function variable(s): 'v' by 'sumFun' is not allowed.
Now, I know I could get around this by simply using
y = arrayfun(difFun,vect);
v = sum(y);
but this misses the whole point of using a reduction variable. The order independent on-gpu difFun should be extremely fast, and the use of the shared variable v should be both fast and memory friendly.
Any thoughts?
Cheers,
-Dan
0 Comments
Accepted Answer
Joss Knight
on 4 Dec 2018
No, you can only read from uplevel variables, and then only one element at a time. You cannot write to them. That is not the intention of GPU arrayfun.
Generally we encourage you to vectorize your code and use MATLAB's own element-wise, reduction and accumulation operations. They are well optimized. If you need to go further than that then you're into the realm of writing your own kernels in CUDA C++. Alternatively, GPU Coder can be used to attempt to combine loops to form kernels that combine various parallel algorithms.
0 Comments
More Answers (0)
See Also
Categories
Find more on GPU Computing in Help Center and File Exchange
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!