How do multiple Answers in a post get Accepted?
Show older comments
What situations allow multiple Answers in a thread (less than a week old) to get Accept-clicked, as seems to have occurred here:
5 Comments
Walter Roberson
on 20 Dec 2012
Neat, I've never seen that before.
I thought perhaps if one had two copies of the question open, but I just tried that and it did not produce this behavior.
Randy Souza
on 20 Dec 2012
Hmm. I'll look into that. My best guess is that the request to accept the first answer hung or took an abnormally long time to load, and in the interim the asker clicked accept for the other answer. It's a bug.
Randy Souza
on 20 Dec 2012
Edited: Randy Souza
on 20 Dec 2012
I'm going to set Matt's answer as the accepted one, because: (1) it was posted earlier (by two whole minutes), (2) according to the database it was accepted earlier, and (3) because the answer code is the same.
However, Kye keeps the 4 reputation points earned for an accepted answer.
Kye Taylor
on 20 Dec 2012
We should both get the points for our rep, and extra points for finding the bug!
Accepted Answer
More Answers (2)
Kye Taylor
on 20 Dec 2012
2 votes
Hahaha thanks @Matt J...
Extra +1 to us for stumbling on the bug!
Image Analyst
on 20 Dec 2012
1 vote
I wonder is Randy is experimenting with the ability to "Unanswer" a question and mark the better one as the "Answer" - something a lot of people have been asking for for a long time, though I suspect he tries this stuff out first on a sandbox, non-production copy of the database rather than the production one.
2 Comments
Randy Souza
on 20 Dec 2012
No, we're still considering the accept-a-different-answer use case, but haven't started on the random experimentation yet :-)
Image Analyst
on 21 Apr 2013
It looks like multiple answers can now be done. Have you added that capability? For example I saw it in this posting. Though only one of the "Answerers" is listed on the main topic view.
Categories
Find more on Historical Contests in Help Center and File Exchange
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!