How can I force simplify function I want?

I have a problem about both simplify and subs functions.
  1. Simplify function is not working in the following example.
syms mu B cc M M_bar E V_N sigma_1;
sigma_1 = sqrt((M+M_bar-4*E*V_N)^2+(2*mu*B)^2);
cantSimplified_Var = simplify(sqrt(4*B^2*mu^sym(2) + 16*E^sym(2)*V_N^2 - 8*E*M*V_N - 8*E*M_bar*V_N + M^2 + 2*M*M_bar + M_bar^2));
isequal(expand(sigma_1),cantSimplified_Var)
ans =
logical
1
isequal(sigma_1,cantSimplified_Var)
ans =
logical
0
2. I want to continue with my new defined function. For example,
syms A B C
A = B^2;
C = A + B^2
C =
2*B^2
Here, I want to see equation like "C = 2*A". Is it possible?
It is related to my first question, because if I can see the expression like "C = 2*A", I will continue my calculation whether MATLAB simplify it correctly or not.

 Accepted Answer

Tell MATLAB to keep slimplfying until it cannot simplify it further (or reaches the iteration limit), then test equality with the isAlways function:
syms mu B cc M M_bar E V_N sigma_1;
sigma_1 = sqrt((M+M_bar-4*E*V_N)^2+(2*mu*B)^2);
cantSimplified_Var = simplify(sqrt(4*B^2*mu^sym(2) + 16*E^sym(2)*V_N^2 - 8*E*M*V_N - 8*E*M_bar*V_N + M^2 + 2*M*M_bar + M_bar^2), 'Steps',500);
Test = isAlways(sigma_1 == cantSimplified_Var)
producing:
Test =
logical
1
.

4 Comments

Thank you for your answer. As I understand your answer, MATLAB can not simplify "cantSimplified_Var" formula to "sqrt((M+M_bar-4*E*V_N)^2+(2*mu*B)^2)". I tried 2000 steps and it gives same results.
My pleasure!
It simplifies as much as it can. The point is that the isAlways function proved the two expressions are the same.
Okay, thank you again.
As always, my pleasure!

Sign in to comment.

More Answers (0)

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!